All-Inclusive Honeymoon Costs Versus Paying As You Go
A couple from Winter Park sent me two quotes last March and asked which one was the better deal. The first was an all-inclusive week in Riviera Maya, two adults, flights from MCO included, 4,380 dollars.

A couple from Winter Park sent me two quotes last March and asked which one was the better deal. The first was an all-inclusive week in Riviera Maya, two adults, flights from MCO included, 4,380 dollars. The second was a room-only rate at a smaller hotel forty minutes down the same coast, 1,910 dollars for the room and 680 for the flights. On paper the second looked like it saved them 1,790 dollars.
It did not. I asked them to write down what they actually eat and drink on vacation, then we priced it. They landed about 260 dollars apart, with the all-inclusive slightly ahead, and the thing that moved the number was not the food. It was airport transfers, two dinners at places that take reservations, and the fact that one of them drinks four cocktails a day on holiday and the other drinks none.
What the word all-inclusive is doing in that price
There is no standard. The phrase is marketing, not a defined package, and the gap between two resorts using the same word can run 40 dollars a day per person.
At the floor end you get buffet meals, house beer and wine, well liquor, and non-motorized water toys. At the top you get the à la carte restaurants without a surcharge, branded liquor, in-room minibar restocked daily, a stocked coffee machine, and sometimes a set number of spa minutes. The brochure for both says all-inclusive in the same typeface.
The line items that get billed separately more often than couples expect, in the order I see them appear on folios:
- Airport transfers, 70 to 150 dollars round trip for two in Cancun or Montego Bay, more in St. Lucia because the drive is longer.
- Specialty restaurants, either a flat 30 to 55 dollars per person or a limit on how many nights you may book.
- Lobster, steak and sushi as supplements inside an otherwise included menu.
- Motorized water sports, so the catamaran is free and the jet ski is 65 dollars for half an hour.
- Resort fee or service charge added at checkout, usually 8 to 18 percent, and not always mentioned at booking.
Ask for the folio sample. Good resorts will send you a redacted one from a past guest if you ask the reservations desk directly rather than going through a booking site. About half say yes.
The two quotes, priced out line by line
This is the comparison I built for that Winter Park couple, for seven nights in late April, two people, departing MCO. I have rounded to the nearest five dollars and left their real drink habit in, because that is the variable people fudge.
| Line item | All-inclusive | Room only |
|---|---|---|
| Flights for two from Orlando | Included | 680 |
| Room, 7 nights | 4,380 total | 1,910 |
| Airport transfers | Included | 115 |
| Breakfast and lunch | Included | 455 |
| Dinners, 5 casual and 2 nicer | Included, 2 nights carry a 40 dollar supplement | 690 |
| Drinks, one heavy drinker | Included | 395 |
| Tips | About 140 in cash | About 210 |
| Resort fee and tax at checkout | Folded into the quote | 175 |
| Running total | 4,600 | 4,630 |
Change one input and the answer flips. Take out the heavy drinker and the room-only trip wins by roughly 400 dollars. Add a third nice dinner and the all-inclusive wins by 500. Move the week to the second half of July and the all-inclusive quote drops about 22 percent while the room-only hotel barely moves, because the big resorts discount hard in low season and small hotels hold their rate.
The advice that all-inclusive always saves money
Every honeymoon checklist tells couples that an all-inclusive is the budget choice. I have tracked enough of these quotes to say that it is roughly a coin flip on cost, and the couples who end up unhappy are usually the ones who chose it for the wrong reason.
The real thing an all-inclusive buys you is the end of small financial decisions. Nine days after a wedding you have made several hundred choices about money, most of them with a deposit deadline attached, and the capacity for another one is gone. Not reaching for a wallet for a week is worth something, and for some couples it is worth more than 300 dollars. That is a legitimate reason to book one. Pretending it is cheaper when your own numbers say otherwise is not.
The counter case is just as real. A room-only booking lets you walk into the town and eat where locals eat, which on the Yucatan coast runs 14 to 22 dollars for two at a decent place and is the part of the trip the couples I follow up with still talk about two years later. Resort food gets dull by day four at every price point I have seen. If you both like food more than you like lounging, the all-inclusive is the expensive option even when the spreadsheet says it is close.
One pattern worth knowing: the hybrid. Three nights all-inclusive to decompress, then four nights at a small hotel somewhere you can walk. It costs slightly more than either single option because you pay for one extra transfer, usually 60 to 90 dollars, and it solves the boredom problem. Roughly a third of the couples I have priced both ways ended up doing this.
How to price your own week in about twenty minutes
Do this before you look at a single resort photo, because the photos will talk you out of arithmetic.
Write down what the two of you ate and drank on your last ordinary vacation, by day, honestly. Then price that at the destination you are considering, using a delivery app set to that city rather than a travel blog, which is the fastest way to get real menu prices. Add transfers both ways, tips at 10 to 15 percent of what you would have spent on food, and the local tourist tax if there is one. Mexico charges a small per-room nightly tax in Quintana Roo, around 4 dollars. The Bahamas adds a VAT of 10 percent that catches people out.
Compare that total against the all-inclusive quote with its supplements added, not the headline rate. If the two are inside 400 dollars of each other, cost is not your deciding factor and you should choose on what the week will feel like instead.
Timing matters more than the choice itself. Book the trip for a date that is not the day after the wedding, protect it with a policy that actually covers named storms if you are traveling between June and November, and if you want to stay inside a three hour flight, our notes on nonstop Caribbean routes out of MCO list weekly costs by island. The rest of our honeymoon planning goes deeper on individual destinations.
One last thing I tell everyone. Ask the resort what their occupancy is for your week. Anything under 60 percent means a quiet pool and some restaurants closed. Over 90 percent means you will be booking dinner at nine o'clock every night. They will usually tell you, and it changes the trip more than the meal plan does.
FAQ
Do honeymoon perks at resorts mean anything?
Sometimes. The ones with real value are a room category upgrade and a late checkout. Sparkling wine and rose petals cost the resort under 20 dollars. Email the resort directly with your wedding date and a copy of the certificate once you have it, rather than ticking a box on a booking site, because the box rarely reaches anyone.
Is a travel agent worth using for this?
For an all-inclusive package, often yes, and usually at no cost to you since the resort pays the commission. For a room-only trip you are assembling yourself, an agent adds little. Ask whether they charge a planning fee before the first call.
When should we pay the balance?
Most packages want the full amount 45 to 60 days before departure. Pay it on a credit card, not a debit card, and keep the deposit receipt. If the resort changes your room category after final payment, that receipt is what gets it fixed.
How much cash should we carry?
About 150 dollars in small bills for a week at an all-inclusive, mostly for housekeeping and bartenders. Double that for a room-only trip where you are paying for taxis and small restaurants. Card acceptance is good at resorts and patchy two streets away from them.
More in Honeymoon
Honeymoon
Honeymoon Downtime and the Games Worth Packing For It
Nobody plans the boring hours of a honeymoon, and there are more of them than the brochure suggests.
Honeymoon
Disney World Honeymoon Planning for Orlando Couples
You live twenty minutes from the most famous honeymoon resort complex in the country, and somehow that makes it harder to book.
Honeymoon
St. Augustine Honeymoon Ideas for Orlando Couples
You want a honeymoon that feels like a real trip, but the wedding drained the budget and neither of you has the energy for...